Having abandoned their responsibilities almost immediately after President Donald J. Trump was inaugurated and continuing to relinquish their authority, Senate Republicans have cemented their place in history as moral failures.
Their first failure came with confirming the appointments of nominees who were woefully unqualified and continues with the Iran war.
Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem allowed ICE agents to roam the streets like thugs. FBI director Kash Patel used $75,000 to $100,000 in government funds to fly to Milan and party like a frat boy with the men’s U.S. hockey team. Former Fox News personality, now Secretary of Defense, Pete Hegseth talks about the death and destruction of combat with braggadocio and bravado and, based on race or gender, has blocked four colonels from being promoted to general.
Now that we are engaged in war with Iran, Congress—the only entity with authority to declare war under Article 1, Section 8—declines to demand that Trump articulate a coherent set of objectives. No surprise that Trump maintains that combat operations in Iran do not constitute war. To do otherwise would be to concede he failed to obtain congressional approval.
Senate Democrats have repeatedly proposed resolutions aimed at halting the war, but as of May 13, Senate Republicans have blocked those efforts seven times. All the while,
the administration provides inconsistent messaging about the war’s objectives and assessments.
Why is it Republicans don’t exercise their constitutional authority? Answer: they fear losing office should they buck Trump and being “primaried.” They are enamored with—perhaps, addicted to—the prestige that comes with being in Congress. But prestige vanishes with death.
The freedom to speak in the absence of risk is evident when listening to Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., who is not running for reelection, or Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., who retired from the House. Both have been critical of either the administration or Trump himself. Most recently, having just lost the primary, Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., has criticized Trump’s $1.8 billion “anti-weaponization” fund and the $1 billion he wants for ballroom security and now supports a resolution to stop the war in Iran.
But courage is measured by how one acts when there is much to lose. Standing firm on principle can be costly. But once you become comfortable with the loss you fear, decision making comes easily.
Republicans might benefit from reading Malcolm Gladwell’s, “The Bomber Mafia,” the history of strategic bombing in WW II. General Curtis LeMay, a man not given to emotion, directed the air campaign against Japan. One of his pilots confessed his fear of dying. LeMay’s reply: “Ralph, you’re probably going to get killed, so it’s better to accept it. You’ll get along much better.”
Placing self-preservation ahead of duty means failing the public. As John F. Kennedy wrote in “Profiles in Courage,” “It is when the politician loves neither the public good nor himself, or when his love for himself is limited and is satisfied by the trappings of office, that the public interest is badly served.”
Great men risk their lives for principle. After being held as a POW and routinely tortured for a year in North Vietnam, the late Senator John McCain, R-Az., then a Navy pilot, was offered an early release in 1968—a propaganda stunt based on McCain’s father, an admiral, being named the commander of all U.S. Pacific forces. McCain refused. “I just knew it wasn’t the right thing to do.” He remained a POW for another four and half years.
Lawmakers in D.C. are asked to do little in comparison—just do their jobs, fulfill their constitutional obligations, and do what is best for the country—but for them losing office is unthinkable.
Republicans senators are finally signaling they’ve had enough; Trump’s “anti-weaponization fund and plans for enhanced ballroom security are too much. Or maybe the senators will just loudly grouse, only to later cave. And if they cave, as they have before, their legacy will be one of shame.
________________________________
Jack D’Aurora writes for Considerthisbyjd.com
_________________________________________________
Well said, Jack. Sad day for America when the secretary of defense for the leading military on the planet is a talk show host whose military experience is largely in a support role in the national guard, not a warfighter like you. And who has been accused of womanizing and excessive drinking. And allowed his wife in on secret group chats that put war fighters at great risk. Some of his predecessors like James Forrestal, Melvin Laird and Elliot Richardson would be rolling in their graves with the antics of Hegseth.
Dear Jack,
Regardless of whether the next round of President Trump’s continual authoritarian moves are resisted by Republican Senators, their legacy has long since been cemented as one of shame. So I respectfully take issue with your last sentence. Absent a conviction vote on a(nother) House impeachment (which will not happen), the stain is devastatingly permanent.
Within the last 24 hours, another 7 top military promotions, mostly involving Blacks and women, have been set aside by Secretary Hegseth. In addition, Trump has just appointed Bill Pulte as acting Director of National Intelligence. If one thought Tulsi Gabbard was a poor choice–and she was–Pulte, with zero intelligence experience, is even worse. I fully expect strong Senate pushback on this one, especially since Senators Cornyn and Cassidy have no discernible reason to further kowtow to President Trump.
I realize that courage is not an easy thing to have, especially when there is invariably an immediate and scathing payback from President Trump, and that it is all too easy for us sitting in the bleachers, so to speak, to condemn others–in this case, U.S. Senators–for not doing the ‘right thing.’ Nevertheless, their withering in the face of genuine Constitutional crises is another species entirely. That is crossing an existential line in the sand.
Having said that, let’s face it, the majority of Republican voters are not in revolt, or even in opposition, to President Trump. And they control the outcome of their party’s Congressional primary elections. So…is it the Republican Senators alone we should consider, or is there be a much broader spectrum of shame that is (or should be) in play here?
Jack and Pat…agree and agree. These evil and corrupt leaders did not get to their positions without voters. They’ve sold their souls to the highest bidders and are doing everything in their power to remain in power and ensure they turn America into a fascist country.
I am bewildered on a daily basis on how we the people are struggling to turn this tide. While I don’t have a Senator’s voice, I can at least continue to pressure my federal representatives to push back and leverage their congressional authority, actively engage in local/state politics for the betterment of our communities, and encourage my family, friends and neighbors to resist and not perpetuate the demise of our country. I’ve lost friendships and strained relationships but I refuse to simply give our democracy to this fascist criminal.
Thank you both.
I like your attitude, Nancy. I’m a big believer in letting our officials know how we feel. I contact my congressman and two senataors twice a month. Will I change their minds? Probably not, but somebody in those offices is taking note about how the constituents are responding to what the president is doing and what Congress is NOT doing.
Most Republicans holding office or voting along those party lines are beyond hope. They cannot admit they are wrong about Trump and all his actions. He is not a Savior. He is an evil person who seems to suck common sense out of all who follow and hold office. We cannot fix the STUPID of these voters and office holders. God help America.
Thanks Jack and others who commented for speaking out on this POS administration and the enablers (elected and voters) who caused it and continue the destruction of our basic, democratic norms, values and institutions. Resistance takes many forms and always courage. Always appreciate yours please keep up the good work!